Book Review: The Rise of the Empress Series – A Juxtaposition Between Good versus Evil; In Which the Good was Great and the Evil was Boring

TEXT: Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, Julie C. Dao (left); Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix, Julie Dao (right)

The Rise of the Empress duology was a thoroughly unexpected series, and, even more unexpected, was that reading these two books reminded me of two important things. First, sometimes your expectations are completely wrong and that you should check them at the door. Second, that it’s not always a bad idea to give a series a second chance.

The Rise of the Empress duology written by Julie Dao consists of two books: the first is Forest of a Thousand Lanterns and the second, which takes place years later but centers on a different character (and thus can be read as a standalone if the reader wishes), is called Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix. As a whole, the Rise of the Empress duology is an East-Asian reimagining of Snow White, set in a fantasy world inspired by the Far East.

Book One: Forest of a Thousand Lanterns


Eighteen-year-old Xifeng is beautiful. The stars say she is destined for greatness, that she is meant to be Empress of Feng Lu. But only if she embraces the darkness within her. Growing up as a peasant in a forgotten village on the edge of the map, Xifeng longs to fulfill the destiny promised to her by her cruel aunt, the witch Guma, who has read the cards and seen glimmers of Xifeng’s majestic future. But is the price of the throne too high?

Because in order to achieve greatness, she must spurn the young man who loves her and exploit the callous magic that runs through her veins–sorcery fueled by eating the hearts of the recently killed. For the god who has sent her on this journey will not be satisfied until his power is absolute.

My review:

Forest of a Thousand Lanterns follows eighteen-year old Xifeng, a peasant girl in a forgotten village, whose witch-aunt foretells a future of darkness, magic, royalty, and immense power. With her beauty, wit, and ambition, Xifeng leaves her village and sets on a path to claim her foretold place on the throne, under the tutelage of an evil god who thirsts for power – but with great cost. And thus, I read Forest of a Thousand Lanterns in October 2017 after I heard overwhelmingly positive reviews that praised the antiheroine and villain origin story narrative, Xifeng’s wicked and compelling characterisation, and atmospheric scenery and worldbuilding.

Unfortunately, I found Forest of a Thousand Lanterns incredibly underwhelming. Although I was excited for the worldbuilding in Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, particularly for its East-Asian influences, I found that the worldbuilding lacked the richness and consistency. I do not believe that worldbuilding should embody an essentalist notion of ‘Chineseness’ or ‘Asianness’ – because, after all, what does that even mean? – but the East-Asian influences were confusing and awkward, perhaps due to the way that the exposition was conveyed and delivered.

The worldbuilding, however, was not at all a problem compared to Xifeng’s characterisation. For all the praise for Xifeng, a woman who was wicked, ambitious, and clever, I did not find Xifeng to be compelling nor complex. I struggled to feel invested in her character arc; perhaps it was the writing style, which I found to be lacking an active tense which consequently undermined the importance of significant scenes, or perhaps Xifeng’s characterisation and development was predictable and inconsistent. Indeed, there were times where her values confused me and the ‘inner conflict’ that she felt lacked depth.

There were many characters in the book that had the potential to be interesting and compelling. The romance between Xifeng and Wei, whom the former claimed to be deeply in love with the latter, lacked chemistry; in particular, I found that the strong feelings and possessiveness that she claimed to feel were forced. Furthermore, I was particularly interested in the characters that clashed with Xifeng’s worldview and ambitions, and how this would challenge her as a character. To my disappointment however, the characters I found to be interesting were relegated to the sidelines whilst the characters that I found to be bland and predictable were developed in their stead.

All in all, Forest of a Thousand Lanterns was a mediocre and lacklustre story; one I found disappointing for all my high hopes for a sweeping Asian-inspired fantasy about an antiheroine’s rise to power. I didn’t feel invested in Xifeng’s story, and thus felt little motivation to read its sequel, Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix. And then I heard that Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix was possible to read as a standalone as it centered on another character, in another time, and in another world. And so, I gave this series another chance – and I’m glad that I did, in the end.

My conclusion: not recommended

(Though, I would recommend reading Forest of a Thousand Lanterns if you intend to read Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix.)

Goodreads | Book Depository | My short review on Goodreads

Is this book for you?

Premise in a sentence: An antiheroine strikes a deal with a dark god and rises to power to become the Empress.

Perfect for: Readers who enjoy antiheroine narratives; who enjoy dark retellings.

Think twice if: You’re looking for rich worldbuilding; like an active voice in storytelling.

Genre: young adult fantasy

Trigger/content warnings: physical abuse, violence, murder, gore, mutilation, intended rape

Book Two: Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix


32605122Princess Jade has grown up in exile, hidden away in a monastery while her stepmother, the ruthless Xifeng, rules as empress of Feng Lu. But the empire is in distress and its people are sinking into poverty and despair. Even though Jade doesn’t want the crown, she knows she is the only one who can dethrone the empress and set the world right. Ready to reclaim her place as rightful heir, Jade embarks on a quest to raise the Dragon Lords and defeat Xifeng and the Serpent God once and for all. But will the same darkness that took Xifeng take Jade, too? Or will she find the strength within to save herself, her friends, and her empire?

My review:

Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix is set many years after the events of Forest of a Thousand Lanterns. The protagonist of the first book, Xifeng, has now been Empress for over a decade, and her empire and its people have suffered in the hands of her selfish and ruthless regime. Enter Jade, stepdaughter of Xifeng, who has hidden away in a monastery in exile and has lived a humble life. When Xifeng summons Jade to the palace to take her place in the royal court, Jade suspects that Xifeng has more planned for Jade beyond making amends to a stepdaughter she never knew. And thus Jade embarks on a quest to summon the Dragon Lords to dethrone and defeat Xifeng and her god for good.

I have to admit: I went in with Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix with tempered expectations. However, I was intrigued by the fact that Jade was completely unlike Xifeng – to many people’s chagrin – and that this story was a quest story. I actually really do love quest stories: though sometimes formulaic, I love quest stories and how they intertwine with self-discovery character arcs, that new lands are explored (which thus offer an opportunity for the writer to really show us the depth and creativity of their world), meeting different people who contrast with the main characters in values, thought, and motivations, and how quests are always about resilience, friendship, and inner strength.

To my surprise, I actually found myself really enjoyed Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix. For one, Dao’s writing significantly improved since Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, and I found myself readily engaging with the material with every chapter. Additionally, Jade was a brilliant character. Indeed, she may be no antiheroine nor does she have a drop of wickedness in her heart, but I found her earnest approach to justice, goodness, and friendship incredibly refreshing, particularly when juxtaposed with the grim era of Xifeng’s regime. More importantly, whereas I did not really care for Xifeng and her success, I wanted Jade to win and I rooted for her at every step.

Additionally, the relationships in Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix were wonderful. In contrast to Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, which felt like the relationships were shoe-horned and lacked depth, the friendships and love in this story were genuine and heartfelt. There was friends-to-lovers (and I loved how Jade and her love interest come together in mutual love for storytelling and respect), found-family between two motherless women, and the poignant and bittersweet maternal love that transcended time and space.

Above all, the ending was incredibly satisfying; epic, emotional, and left me feeling content with the overall series. Although I didn’t particularly enjoy Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, I would recommend the book on the basis of, either, that you might like it and enjoy the antiheroine/villain origin story or you are interested to read Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix. Although you certainly don’t have the prequel to enjoy Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix, I recommend it nonetheless; you will find subtle nods to elements of Forest of a Thousand Lanterns, and some really emotional moments in this book will have more meaning and significance if you have read the prequel.  

My conclusion: recommended

Goodreads | Book Depository | My short review on Goodreads

Is this book for you?

Premise in a sentence: A princess in exile returns to her kingdom and goes on a quest to summon a powerful force that can bring down the corrupt Empress.

Perfect for: Readers who like adventure stories; readers who enjoyed Forest of a Thousand Lanterns and want to meet the antithesis of Xifeng; readers who enjoy found-family relationships.

Think twice if: You’re not a fan of reading about ‘the good hero(ine)’; don’t enjoy quest/adventure narratives.

Genre: young adult fantasy

Trigger/content warnings: graphic murder and violence, fantasy violence, blood mentions, death, death of loved one

I have to say, this series humbled me. Even though I would consider myself an experienced book blogger, I fell into the trap of judging a book by it’s hype.

I also might have missed out on a great sequel if I had not given the series another chance! This makes me think about all the series I could become invested in if I gave their sequels another go. Or, should a first book be indicative of the rest of the series?

  • What do you think? Do you think we should give a sequel a chance, even if we didn’t like the first book much?
  • Have you read either Forest of a Thousand Lanterns or The Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix? What did you think?
  • What’s your fave: antiheroine stories or heroine stories? 👀

17 thoughts on “Book Review: The Rise of the Empress Series – A Juxtaposition Between Good versus Evil; In Which the Good was Great and the Evil was Boring

  1. Thank you for doing this post. It’s a great way to look at it.

    I had similar problems with Forest. My biggest one was pacing, IIRC. Xifeng being the Evil Queen, I remember there were times when I kept having to ask myself when she’d actually get to E.Q. level of actions because it didn’t really seem like she did for a looong time.

    I’ve got Kingdom on my table to try, though, so here’s hoping I’ll enjoy it as you did. 🙂


  2. Great reviews! I’ve been seeking out more Asian-inspired fantasy and I remember considering picking Forest of a Thousand Lanterns up when it first started making the rounds on the blogosphere, but something kept putting me off reading it. I’m not actually the biggest fan of villain origin stories because I think they’re rarely done well, especially if the villain in question is a woman. I hated Disney’s Maleficent film, for example, because it took a compelling villain from the original who literally described herself as ‘the mistress of all evil’ and turned her into a woman who threw a tantrum because a man broke her heart. I’m so bored of lady villains having origin stories centred around men.

    Knowing that I could just skip to the second book in this duology, though, has me intrigued! Jade’s story sounds far more interesting to me and I love characters who are well-written nice people, because I think it’s actually quite difficult to write compelling nice people without them seeming saccharine. Out of curiosity, have you read The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison? It’s my favourite novel and it also features a genuinely nice character ascending to a throne he doesn’t want. I think you might like it if you enjoyed Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix! 🙂


  3. Great reviews, CW ❤️ I always give the sequels a chance especially if they are companion novels. I would love to read more anti heroine stories because I haven’t found many books with that concept yet.


  4. Great review CW! I really enjoyed Forest, even though the pacing and world building kinda snags at me too. But I found Xi Feng to be a character I could root for, she started out as an abused, lowly village girl. She does have her ambition, and to achieve that it’s both fascinating and compelling to see what she would give up and the lengths she would go- she give up her love, conscience, and a possible mother/daughter relationship, if not female companionship, she never had in the form of the queen. Being in her head scares me, but it’s also pretty compelling. I haven’t read Kingdom, but I do have it on my TBR and it’s on my priority for this year! 🙂


  5. Giving the sequel a chance after a not-so-great first book really if the premise is engaging enough to capture your curiosity then I guess it is a worthwhile risk to dive into the second book. Like what happened to me with Warcross, I read it and I couldn’t care less with what’s going on so I just decided not to read the sequel Wildcard 😆


  6. These were great reviews ❤ I'm happy to hear you enjoyed Kingdom, but a little sad you were disappointed by Forest. Then again, I guess even with years of experience book blogging, we can never really be immune to all of the hype, can we. 🙂 I enjoyed Forest, so I'm even more looking forward to reading Kingdom, you make it sound really good ❤ Thank you so much for sharing! ❤


  7. Great review! It’s so interesting that I felt exactly the same way! I just wasn’t invested in Xifeng as a character, but I was rooting for Jade the entire time.


  8. This is really interesting. To be totally honest, I would not pick up a sequel if I didn’t like the first book. It’s just so rare – in my experience – that the second book will be better (let’s face it it’s usually worse) that most of the time I can’t summon up the enthusiasm to continue. You have challenged my worldview though! Maybe I should start giving my authors more of an opportunity to develop.

    Does it count as an anti-heroine if they aren’t 100% evil? Cause if so my answer would have to be To Kill a Kingdom.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s totally fair! In most cases, I wouldn’t pick up a sequel if I didn’t like the first book either, but when I read that it reads as a standalone… 👀 I was so curious.

      Yes, definitely! And in the case of FOTL vs KotBP, the latter is a SIGNIFICANT improvement. It was really lovely.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Honestly I probably skipped the first one as I feel villain stories rely too much on you liking the idea versus fleshing them out. But I might check out the second one as I like quests and niceness in the face of bad things.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Oh! I didn’t know that these two books were based off separate characters and could be read as standalones? I just assumed that it was like a Duology Duology. But that’s amazing! I might just real Forest of a Thousand Lanterns before I read Kingdom of a Blazing Phoenix, just so that I understand the references more ❤

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, you definitely can! I agree with reading FOTL first because it makes a LOT of references across, and enhanced my reading experience of KotBP! 💛 I hope you enjoy FOTL more than I did – it wasn’t just for me, but I hope it will be for you!

      Liked by 1 person

  11. Thank you for your honest review (and why didn’t you tell me you didn’t like it sooner?!!?!). I am really glad that you gave the series a second chance and that the second book worked for you, that’s so interesting. I like that each can be read as a standalone, though!

    Liked by 1 person

    • 😭😭😭
      I know oodles of people who loved it and tbh, I’m an outlier! And for me, it was just one of those, it’s not you, it’s me sort of books!

      Right? It doesn’t happen often, and I’m more inclined to feel silly for continuing with a story but, I’m glad it worked out in the end for me!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s